Bars

Marytown Tap

4.6 254 reviews 11:00 AM - 2:00 AM W904 Kiel Rd, New Holstein, WI 53061, United States

Discover this place

Marytown Tap is not just another bar; it's a vibrant meeting place nestled in New Holstein, WI, where community spirit thrives. Offering a cozy yet trendy ambiance, it welcomes everyone with wheelchair accessibility and ample parking. Patrons rave about their excellent food, from mouth-watering Cajun Salmon to delectable wraps and shareable appetizers like beer-battered onion hot scoops. The extensive beer selection and signature cocktails are perfect for enjoying while catching a game or engaging in bar games with friends. With friendly staff and a commitment to great service, Marytown Tap is a must-visit for anyone seeking fun and delicious dining.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery

Highlights

Bar games
Fast service
Great beer selection
Great cocktails
Sports

Popular for

Solo dining

Dining options

Table service

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy
Trendy

Crowd

Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Marytown Tap before visiting.

Reviews for Marytown Tap

4.6

254 reviews

100%

31%

Review highlights

Based on 254 reviews

Marytown Tap in New Holstein is widely praised for its welcoming atmosphere, attentive service, and diverse menu offerings. Reviewers frequently highlight the friendly and knowledgeable staff, who contribute to a positive dining experience. The bar's Friday Fish Fry and seafood dishes, such as Cajun salmon, receive consistent acclaim for quality and flavor. Patrons appreciate the generous portions, reasonable prices, and large selection of beers, making it a favorite local destination. Additionally, the spacious interior and availability of games add to the venue’s appeal. Overall, Marytown Tap is seen as a reliable spot for flavorful, well-prepared food paired with excellent service and a casual, enjoyable environment.

Jen

Apr 21, 2025

We've been here many many times for the Friday Fish Fry. It is definitely one our favorites as well as a local favorite. Great service and a delicious Friday fish fry menu with something for everyone. Do yourself a favor and stop by! You won't regret it. The owners are amazing and provide knowledgeable staff who will cater to your every need.

Dena Weidner

Apr 11, 2025

We frequent the Tap quite a bit, and the food has always been wonderful. Last night I got the Cajun Salmon and it was perfectly cooked! My husband had the philly wrap and he greatly enjoyed it. The staff is always so friendly. We will be back again soon!

Jenny Jorgensen

Apr 02, 2025

Our 1st time here! We will be back and soon! Excellent service, friendly bartender, amazing food, great prices, large portions and awesome atmosphere! Worth the drive!

Linda

Mar 24, 2025

Great food.. Great prices.

Lisa Ditter

Mar 16, 2025

Lady bartender was GREAT and proficient when out tractorcade showed up during some wedding celebration. Don't know her name but she ROCKED the entire bar by herself! Tons of space inside, vast beer selection, parking and LOTS of games. Menu had pretty much anything you'd want and DECENT prices. Give them a try, I don't think you'll be disappointed!

S.D. Driskill

Feb 06, 2025

Didn't get to try the food, maybe next time. Was very spacious, more than I thought it would be. The menu looked interesting.

SHANE PEIK

Feb 03, 2025

They always have excellent food and service, and the old fashioned's are good too! Try the bacon wrapped shrimp. You will come back again too!

Matt Hildebrand

Dec 30, 2024

Ordered 3 fish dinner to go. Called in and had my meal 15 minutes later. Asked some questions, and the staff was great at answering